Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts

Tuesday, 2 July 2013

US Power and International Finance

I was reading Stephen Walt's Taming American Power (published in 2005) and it spoke of the importance of other states replicating US financial practices in order to stabilise the international financial system and prevent shocks. 

This would be hilarious if it weren't so tragic. The US and its allies (both states and institutions such as the IMF and the World Bank) have pressed states around the world to adopt economic and financial policies which benefit US capital. 

What did this achieve? A mutually-beneficial financial stability? Far from it, as the 2007-9 'American crisis' (Leo Panitch and Sam Gindin's apt phrase) which resulted in considerable shocks worldwide demonstrates. 

All it has done is entrench structural global inequalities based on institutions and practices which overwhelming benefit the already-dominant United States.

It's time those of us who want a world based on equality of opportunity, human rights and democracy to recognise that Western governments are not the advocates of these principles except in rhetorical terms. That they talk about political freedoms as a means of obscuring us from the area where human rights and democracy are most important: in the socio-economic realm. 

The Importance of Economics

This morning I was watching last Thursday's edition of the BBC's Question Time. As with most times I watch a political programme on the television, I was overcome with the desire to throw my mug at the television.

The 'discussion' around the government's economic policy was entirely uneducated. The audience repeatedly made comments about how borrowing in order to solve our economic problems was 'illogical' which was faced with no challenge by the panel. This is basic economic knowledge. If the government were to borrow £10bn and invest it in infrastructure (for example, much-needed housebuilding) they would see a return on this money by way of taxes through the creation of jobs and boosting of economic growth. This is seriously basic and it is what is being recommended by the IMF and espoused by the Labour Party. This is especially advisable policy given the lack of economic growth and the very low interest rates on government borrowing.

That even the Labour representative on the panel didn't speak up about this demonstrates how far this government has framed the debate on economic policy to its own outdated dogma.

What the 2008-9 crisis demonstrated to us is the extent that states are fundamental to the economy. In fact, the whole category of 'the economy' is a false one. This categorisation (which goes back to the classical economists of the nineteenth century at least) presents 'the economy' as something natural, autonomous and somehow external to society. Through this, elites are able to present the economy as something which 'we' cannot control, only understand. Thus 'economics' is studied as though it were a natural science. In fact, it is highly political and highly social.

We need to challenge this alienation of the economic. We need to demonstrate how 'the market' and 'the economy' are neither irresistible forces nor immovable objects but fundamentally human creations. Because of this, they change all the time and are much more complicated than basic concepts such as 'balancing the books' suggest. Governments do not follow the logic of households: that if you spend less, you will have more. In fact, they are more like businesses in this sense: you need to spend money to make money and then you can use that money for the goods you want. For business leaders that may mean private jets and diamond rings, for the government it means healthcare, welfare and education.

All of this convinces me further that I want to pursue a career in the field of political economy. It is time we recognise the political and historically-contingent nature of 'the economy'. My dream would be to write a series of books on political economy aimed at children, teenagers and those without a formal education. Only through educating people about political economy can we hope for real progressive global change and a world where we are not at the mercy of the whims of international financial leaders.

Tuesday, 22 May 2012

The changing nature of war

I was reading an article today from 1998 about international theory. The contemporary consensus was that globalisation meant that social and economic forces were superseding traditional great power politics. This is undoubtedly the case today. As shown by the ongoing economic crisis, the power of the 'markets' as controlled by global capitalists is devastating and seemingly immovable in the face of governments worldwide.

What some scholars concluded to the scepticism of the article's author was that this would lead to fewer wars between nations. Looking around these scholars were correct that there would be fewer traditional wars fought between states. Where they were wrong was in their optimism: groups and actors are fighting and oppressing each other as much as always but in new (and in some cases old) ways. States worldwide are murdering and torturing those whose interests they are supposed to represent while so-called liberal democracies such as the US and the UK are complicit in barbaric torture practices. Traditional rules of war and humanitarian principles are abandoned in the pursuit of the war on terrorism, a word so vague it can be used to a apply to any actor or group a state deems as behaving or believing contrary to its interests. Thus Syria's forces describe those they oppress as terrorists.

History teaches us to be optimistic about the end of current struggles but not to expect whatever comes next to be any better.

Saturday, 21 April 2012

Why economic growth should not be at the heart of our global development goals


In 2000 every member of the UN signed up to a set of millennium development goals (MDGs) due to be achieved by 2015. As the deadline approaches, the targets seem less and less attainable, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. The inevitable question is: why have we not gone further in achieving the MDGs?

A variety of answers have been supplied, all of which have some validity. Some argue that the goals were too top-down, did not focus enough on economic development or were simply too ambitious. This debate is probably premature: the deadline is still three years away and until we have the full data it is impossible to say which goals were hardest to achieve, where and why.

However, with the announcement on 13 April that David Cameron is set to chair a UN committee establishing a new set of development goals for after 2015 and the upcoming Rio+ summit in June which is due to decide on a set of sustainable development goals critically evaluating the MDGs is now essential.
For Cameron, the focus is likely to be on arranging the goals around economic growth with an emphasis on private sector involvement. This is worrying.

It would be disingenuous to deny the positive effect economic development has had on the MDG outcomes in China; economic growth can be harnessed to achieve fantastic results. However, in and of itself it does not improve healthcare, provide education or reduce inequality. In many instances, it can exacerbate existing problems or create new ones in these areas - when economic growth is not harnessed for good by an effective government it can mean more for the rich and less for the poor. Case studies demonstrating this have been highlighted in a book called Dying for Growth co-edited by new leader of the World Bank Jim Yong Kim.

Cameron has used his positive move to commit to 0.7% of the UK’s GDP on aid as a stepping stone to enforce his outdated and potentially disastrous view about world development. Unless this focus on economic growth is clearly stipulated to mean only economic growth for all the next set of goals will be worse and not better than the MDGs.

Take a comparison of two countries for which data is available regarding achievement of the MDGs: India and Cuba. India has achieved remarkable economic growth in recent decades while Cuba’s has been more or less stagnant. And yet Cuba has already achieved three of its MDG targets, being on course to achieve most of the rest while India looks set to fail on almost all counts. What is the reason for this difference? The answer is political will.

While the private sector has its place in global development this should be on the sidelines, as a supplement and an indirect actor. The drive for profits will not help those who are so in need of real achievement in the field of development. What will help are governments who have the political desire to make the vast improvements required. Economic growth can only be a supporter of this; it cannot be the driving factor.

I will leave the last word to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon from the 2011 MDGs report: 'Achieving the [millenium development] goals will require equitable and inclusive economic growth - growth that reaches everyone and that will enable all people, especially the poor and marginalised, to benefit from economic opportunities.'



This article originally appeared in Voices of the 7 Billion

Sunday, 25 March 2012

A Taste of Serbia

I recently returned from a trip to Belgrade, the capital of former Yugoslavian country Serbia. If I'd been hoping for a relaxing, cheery holiday I would most definitely have been disappointed. The museums were lacklustre, the streets lined with rubbish and very few restaurants used the Latin alphabet making trying to decipher the Cyrillic words of a menu the biggest activity of my visit (as a vegetarian this was especially difficult).

My trip was certainly an interesting one, however. I spent an afternoon with two men who work in the sex industry. While the two men were friends (often working together as a safety measure) their circumstances were very different. One man, we'll call him Tomas, was very confident with his role and, he explained to me through an interpreter, very much enjoyed having sex with his male clients. He even proudly showed me intimate pictures of himself dressed in revealing women's clothing (and one of him not dressed at all). The other sex worker - whom I shall refer to as Raz - did not feel happy with job he did for a living. As a man from the Roma community, Raz feels utter shame with what he does for money. That he still lives with his parents brings this shame to him everyday. So while Tomas experiences many of the difficulties that all sex workers face: occasional abuse from clients, persecution from arbitrary laws and practices towards those perceived as 'prostitutes' on the streets of Belgrade, Raz endures this and more. Tomas's parents know that he is gay, even if he hasn't explained to them how he pays the rent each month. Raz could never tell his family that he sells sex. When he was imprisoned for soliciting sex, he lie to his family about why he was there: 'It would be less shameful to tell my family I murdered someone than admit I am a prostitute.'

What my encounter with Tomas and Raz taught me was that I, despite considering myself open-minded - had been completely blind to the wider picture about sex workers. Not only are they not just women: they're not just exploited and they're not just victims. There are a whole complex set of reasons why a person sells sex ranging from those who are trafficked for sexual exploitation to those whose economic situation pushes them there through to those who have an active desire to sell sex for no other reason than that they want to. This is not a perversion and it does not necessarily mean they have been abused, or forced into doing this.

My meeting with Raz was also my first encounter with the difficulties faced by the Roma community in Serbia. For while Serbia's overall unemployment rate is 40%, discrimation is such that the figure is probably double for Roma people who, as far as a I could see, live in what amounts to small-scale shanty towns dotted around the city.

Above all Belgrade was a miserable place to be. The abandoned construction works, bombed buildings, and extremist graffiti were the biggest factors in this. But the largest contributor to this feeling of malaise was in the people I met. Above all they were pessimistic about getting jobs, pessimistic about the ability of their government to make any changes for the better, pessimistic about the upcoming elections, pessimistic about any improvement in conditions for the vulnerable when (or if?) Serbia joins the EU and pessimistic about any imminent economic recovery. For Serbians, the future is most certainly not bright.