There are two prevalent themes in literature and general observation about democracy in Africa. The first is heavily influenced by modernisation theory and assumes a teleological development of the state toward liberal democracy. It is observed that the liberal democracies of Europe, North America, Japan, Australia and New Zealand (commonly shorthanded to 'the West') developed gradually over time from feudalism through industrialisation and slowly into the flowering beds of freedom, liberty and equality they are today. The countries of Africa, indeed of all the Second and Third Worlds, will soon and slowly but surely develop into the same kinds of liberal democracy we see in 'the West': strong protection of individual freedom, elected (for the most part - see UK's House of Lords) leaders, along with social and economic liberty. The connection between liberalism and democracy is 'natural' and the presence of both is inherently good: so good, in fact, that Western governments are justified in killing thousands of civilians abroad in the name of protecting and spreading these values. Adherents of this theory used to say that all African countries needed were elections and they'd naturally vote for more liberty (both social and economic) and before long there'd be a bunch of lovely, stable liberal democracies. When the so-called democratisation of Africa began after the Cold War, there were a huge number of elections in 1993. Did these bring peace and stability to Africa? No. The reasons why, many liberalists concluded, revolved around lack of economic growth and lack of civil liberties. As Bratton and van de Walle argued in 1997: elections were not enough in themselves to demonstrate democracy: they must be conducted within a matrix of civil liberties.
As you may have guessed, I am not totally convinced by this teleological view of liberal democracy. I do agree that, as far as political regimes go, the one I live in is more or less as good as it gets: I love my freedoms, I love that I can write a blog post about how much I disagree with David Cameron's policies and that he would proudly uphold my right to do so, I love that I can have a say in the policies of my government through the ballot box. What I disagree with is that the situation I am in is somehow 'natural' or 'inevitable'; that humans objectively desire freedoms and liberties for other people or even for themselves; that there couldn't possibly exist a better political system than a liberal democracy in which I live. I do think it is possible to hold these doubts about liberal democracy whilst also seeing the oppression of other people and wanting it to end. What I want is that those oppressed people can create their own futures - free from what their dictator tells them or what a Western aid agency or government thinks they should want.
This is not to say that I fall into the other dangerous camp of literature on democracy in Africa: the racist one. The one that says Africa cannot have liberal democracy because of its 'culture'; because it is naturally traditional, patrimonial or any other political scientific euphemism for 'backward' you want to throw in. Which isn't to say that the only adherents of this view see it is a necessarily bad thing: there are plenty of African romanticists who view the African system as naturally different from 'the West', as naturally 'traditional' and adverse to modernisation.
The two problems common to both of these theories is that they posit a 'naturalness' or 'objectivity' about a particular political reality which is in fact situated in a highly volatile and fluid historical context. Because one can posit similarities between different regimes or societies across time and space does not make them objectively natural - it makes them comparable and in some way useful to study but does not render them inevitable. The second problem with both of these views of democracy in Africa is that they allow no room for variability within the continent. This is the most common problem I find with literature about politics in Africa and in fact I am wholly unconvinced that there are any generalisations that can be made about the continent. Swathes of articles will make sweeping generalisations based on ten, five or even one country. That there are 57 countries on the continent gives one the sense that the scholarly act of making generalisations should not be taken lightly. This is especially true of democracy where, in Africa, there exist countries which have pretty well-entrenched multi-party democracies (Benin, Ghana, Botswana) while there are also others whose elections have seemed, if anything, to worsen ethnic tensions, violence, and corruption (Democratic Republic of Congo, Kenya, Zimbabwe).
The answer to these issues for scholars is to analyse carefully historical, political and socioeconomic factors of a given state or society, using comparative analysis where appropriate but not as a solve-all tool. The answer for international policy-makers is a whole lot more complicated, but it has to start by shifting their focus from the central and single importance of elections; ending the characterisation of the states of the world as either 'friends' or 'enemies' with the former to be appeased no matter what ills they cause (e.g. Yoweri Museveni in Uganda or Joseph Kabila in DRC); and placing greater responsibility on the corporations who pay taxes to their states while making money off the backs of death, destruction and corruption in authoritarian regimes.
Analysing global politics from a philosophical, practical, and occasionally personal standpoint.
Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts
Sunday, 25 November 2012
Tuesday, 22 May 2012
The changing nature of war
I was reading an article today from 1998 about international theory. The contemporary consensus was that globalisation meant that social and economic forces were superseding traditional great power politics. This is undoubtedly the case today. As shown by the ongoing economic crisis, the power of the 'markets' as controlled by global capitalists is devastating and seemingly immovable in the face of governments worldwide.
What some scholars concluded to the scepticism of the article's author was that this would lead to fewer wars between nations. Looking around these scholars were correct that there would be fewer traditional wars fought between states. Where they were wrong was in their optimism: groups and actors are fighting and oppressing each other as much as always but in new (and in some cases old) ways. States worldwide are murdering and torturing those whose interests they are supposed to represent while so-called liberal democracies such as the US and the UK are complicit in barbaric torture practices. Traditional rules of war and humanitarian principles are abandoned in the pursuit of the war on terrorism, a word so vague it can be used to a apply to any actor or group a state deems as behaving or believing contrary to its interests. Thus Syria's forces describe those they oppress as terrorists.
History teaches us to be optimistic about the end of current struggles but not to expect whatever comes next to be any better.
What some scholars concluded to the scepticism of the article's author was that this would lead to fewer wars between nations. Looking around these scholars were correct that there would be fewer traditional wars fought between states. Where they were wrong was in their optimism: groups and actors are fighting and oppressing each other as much as always but in new (and in some cases old) ways. States worldwide are murdering and torturing those whose interests they are supposed to represent while so-called liberal democracies such as the US and the UK are complicit in barbaric torture practices. Traditional rules of war and humanitarian principles are abandoned in the pursuit of the war on terrorism, a word so vague it can be used to a apply to any actor or group a state deems as behaving or believing contrary to its interests. Thus Syria's forces describe those they oppress as terrorists.
History teaches us to be optimistic about the end of current struggles but not to expect whatever comes next to be any better.
Labels:
capitalism,
democracy,
economy,
globalisation,
international relations,
Syria,
terrorism,
torture,
UK,
US,
war
Wednesday, 29 February 2012
A step in the right direction
First Burma, now North Korea: are the world's pariah states moving towards greater global cooperation? As Burma loosened its grip on domestic freedoms, last year saw the US Secretary of State visit the nation for the first time in decades signifying a thawing in international relations. In a move that many have seen as an attempt to weaken reliance upon China, Burma seems to be changing for the better. Is North Korea now making the same step (and, perhaps, for the same reason)? Today it was announced that, in exchange for US food supplies, North Korea would suspend its nuclear programme.
We can only hope that all nations will take a leaf out off these countries' books in moving toward cooperation and negotiation for the greater good. For while both the isolationism and the oppression of human rights of North Korea and Burma are on the extreme end of the scale, every country could benefit from some self-reflection, greater co-operation and democratic changes on the path to greater good for all.
We can only hope that all nations will take a leaf out off these countries' books in moving toward cooperation and negotiation for the greater good. For while both the isolationism and the oppression of human rights of North Korea and Burma are on the extreme end of the scale, every country could benefit from some self-reflection, greater co-operation and democratic changes on the path to greater good for all.
Labels:
Burma,
cooperation,
democracy,
human rights,
North Korea,
nuclear power,
USA
Saturday, 4 February 2012
Malvinas/Falklands: the only solution
I read an article in the Guardian recently which said that there are a growing number of young Argentinians are seeing the islands their nation calls the Malvinas as British. This is controversial in a country which has always laid claim to these islands. Argentina fought and lost a war with Britain over what the latter call the Falklands in 1982. The debate over sovereignty of the islands has reignited within the last year with Argentina being accused of plotting a 'blockade' against the islands by pressuring Chile to end Port Stanley flights.
For many this spat between Britain and Argentina over the Malvinas/Falklands seems inevitable and one that will never go away. An Argentine president could never cease calling for Argentine control of the Malvinas because the issue is seen as a cornerstone of Argentine patriotism. Equally, a British government could never cede the Falklands because it fought so hard to keep them thirty years ago. This tension is inflamed by the recent discovery of oil off the coast of the islands.
This has got me thinking about what the solution has to be. For me, democracy is the only way to decide. It may be imperfect, the results will undoubtedly be contested, but it's the only means by which this issue can be resolved: a referendum of the people living on the islands. Do they wish their islands to be part of the Argentinian territory, part of the British territory, or self-ruled? If the results were inconclusive (a majority of 50% plus one would be required) then negotiations would be necessary with the UN as the platform for this.
For many this spat between Britain and Argentina over the Malvinas/Falklands seems inevitable and one that will never go away. An Argentine president could never cease calling for Argentine control of the Malvinas because the issue is seen as a cornerstone of Argentine patriotism. Equally, a British government could never cede the Falklands because it fought so hard to keep them thirty years ago. This tension is inflamed by the recent discovery of oil off the coast of the islands.
This has got me thinking about what the solution has to be. For me, democracy is the only way to decide. It may be imperfect, the results will undoubtedly be contested, but it's the only means by which this issue can be resolved: a referendum of the people living on the islands. Do they wish their islands to be part of the Argentinian territory, part of the British territory, or self-ruled? If the results were inconclusive (a majority of 50% plus one would be required) then negotiations would be necessary with the UN as the platform for this.
Monday, 16 January 2012
Long Walk to Freedom
I was listening to Ladysmith Black Mambazo yesterday and one of their songs affected me in particular. Halala South Africa congratulates the group's home country on its transition to democracy. In amongst the powerful lyrics is a reference to Nelson Mandela's lengthy and moving autobiography: Long Walk to Freedom. It suddenly struck me just how extraordinary an achievement the end of the apartheid regime must have seemed both to those directly involved in the struggle for freedom and worldwide observers. Just a few years previously it must have seemed impossible for the regime which had been propped up by both the British and American governments to have fallen.
So what changed? The answer lies in the worldwide events of the time: the fall of the Soviet Union and, with it, the end of the Cold War meant that support for 'capitalist-friendly' abusive regimes such as that of South Africa was no longer so appealing. Something similar occurred for dictatorial regimes in Argentina, Brazil and Chile which had also been propped up both overtly and covertly by the Western side of the Iron Curtain.
This story should give hope to those today who feel like they are swimming up a waterfall. When I speak to people who have either studied or been directly involved in the Israeli-Palestine conflict there is an overwhelming sense of pessimism about the future. The largest source of this pessimism is American and global economic support for the Israeli government in all actions they wish to undertake. While I would not wish to say the two situations are the same: South Africa was one country with a brutal regime which needed toppling entirely; Israel and Palestine are two separate nations at almost complete loggerheads, with one enacting terror over the other through administrative and economic control. However, should American support for Israel ever falter due to some international event comparable to the end of the Cold War, I have no doubt that the nature of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would change dramatically, with both sides much more willing to co-operate if a resolution seemed more likely.
So what changed? The answer lies in the worldwide events of the time: the fall of the Soviet Union and, with it, the end of the Cold War meant that support for 'capitalist-friendly' abusive regimes such as that of South Africa was no longer so appealing. Something similar occurred for dictatorial regimes in Argentina, Brazil and Chile which had also been propped up both overtly and covertly by the Western side of the Iron Curtain.
This story should give hope to those today who feel like they are swimming up a waterfall. When I speak to people who have either studied or been directly involved in the Israeli-Palestine conflict there is an overwhelming sense of pessimism about the future. The largest source of this pessimism is American and global economic support for the Israeli government in all actions they wish to undertake. While I would not wish to say the two situations are the same: South Africa was one country with a brutal regime which needed toppling entirely; Israel and Palestine are two separate nations at almost complete loggerheads, with one enacting terror over the other through administrative and economic control. However, should American support for Israel ever falter due to some international event comparable to the end of the Cold War, I have no doubt that the nature of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would change dramatically, with both sides much more willing to co-operate if a resolution seemed more likely.
Labels:
Cold War,
democracy,
Israel,
Ladysmith Black Mambazo,
Nelson Mandela,
Palestine,
South Africa,
USA
Friday, 13 January 2012
Burma sets free hundreds of political prisoners
How brilliant to see Burma setting free 600 of its political prisoners. Here's hoping the rest will follow shortly. The odds of Aung San Suu Kyi living to see democracy reign in her home country are increasing with every step the Burmese government takes. We can only hope it stays that way.
Monday, 12 December 2011
Does the DRC deserve the D in its name?
Joseph Kabila, the incumbent president of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) has been declared the winner of the recent elections after several days of unexpected delays in announcement of the results. Kabila received the support of just 28% of eligible voters but still received the majority needed to rule due to low voter turnout and a split opposition (11 candidates were running for the presidency).
The second-highest polled candidate, Etienne Tshisekedi, has contested the results, proclaiming himself the elected president of the DRC. However, although a number of voting irregularities were reported, independent international observers have declared these unlikely to affect the result of the poll.
It is extremely difficult in a country like the DRC where sectarianism is a part of daily life to avoid falling to violence over the results of a poll where there are questions about its legitimacy, and where the winner has received such a small percentage of the country's confidence.
However, the latter is an unfortunate by-product of the imperfect democracies in our world. The British Prime Minister David Cameron received the votes of only 23% of those eligible in the general election last year.
We can only hope that the clashes seen in Kinshasa, the DRC's capital at the weekend do not spread, and turn into another civil war in the region.
The second-highest polled candidate, Etienne Tshisekedi, has contested the results, proclaiming himself the elected president of the DRC. However, although a number of voting irregularities were reported, independent international observers have declared these unlikely to affect the result of the poll.
It is extremely difficult in a country like the DRC where sectarianism is a part of daily life to avoid falling to violence over the results of a poll where there are questions about its legitimacy, and where the winner has received such a small percentage of the country's confidence.
However, the latter is an unfortunate by-product of the imperfect democracies in our world. The British Prime Minister David Cameron received the votes of only 23% of those eligible in the general election last year.
We can only hope that the clashes seen in Kinshasa, the DRC's capital at the weekend do not spread, and turn into another civil war in the region.
Thursday, 8 December 2011
Why we shouldn't worry about Islamism
Egypt's recent election has followed a pattern in the Middle East: Islamists have taken the majority of the votes. This has followed the success of Islamist An-Nadha in Tunisia and the Islamic Justice and Development party in Morocco. This has inevitably led to a massive debate in countries such as the UK and especially France over what this means. The usual anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic scaremongering has been trotted out.
This is not to deny that it is a difficult issue for libertarians such as myself: on the one hand I support democracy and diversity and the legitimacy of their choice of leaders and representatives; on the other hand I have a natural aversion to giving religion an explicit place in politics and to the reduced level of freedoms religious states tend to allow their citizens.
However, I remind myself, and others in this position, the respect I and others in democratised developed countries have for democracy and freedom of speech does not exist worldwide and for good reason.
We revere democracy because, for the most part, it has worked. It has provided us with human rights, economic prosperity, and freedoms unimagined a mere century or two ago. This is not the case for countries such as Tunisia and Egypt who have only seen a sham democracy.
For a lot of people in Arab (and other) countries Islam is far more important politically than the concepts of ‘liberalism’ and ‘democracy’ where these concepts have been nothing but shams. Where a president receives 99.9% of the vote in ‘elections’ and gives a front of liberalism while disregarding the basic press and political freedoms (not to mention the economic and social ones) of the people. If these and future elections are successful, Tunisians’ faith in the processes of democracy will be strengthened, and the natural equation between Islam and politics in many minds will fade.
While it is my ideal that people’s personal religious beliefs be kept out of politics (at least in the most overt way), I also accept that the practical and actual experiences of real people and real countries are not always conducive to this. I also accept that my views will not necessarily be correct. And that there are different paths to the greatest democracy for different countries and different people.
This is not to deny that it is a difficult issue for libertarians such as myself: on the one hand I support democracy and diversity and the legitimacy of their choice of leaders and representatives; on the other hand I have a natural aversion to giving religion an explicit place in politics and to the reduced level of freedoms religious states tend to allow their citizens.
However, I remind myself, and others in this position, the respect I and others in democratised developed countries have for democracy and freedom of speech does not exist worldwide and for good reason.
We revere democracy because, for the most part, it has worked. It has provided us with human rights, economic prosperity, and freedoms unimagined a mere century or two ago. This is not the case for countries such as Tunisia and Egypt who have only seen a sham democracy.
For a lot of people in Arab (and other) countries Islam is far more important politically than the concepts of ‘liberalism’ and ‘democracy’ where these concepts have been nothing but shams. Where a president receives 99.9% of the vote in ‘elections’ and gives a front of liberalism while disregarding the basic press and political freedoms (not to mention the economic and social ones) of the people. If these and future elections are successful, Tunisians’ faith in the processes of democracy will be strengthened, and the natural equation between Islam and politics in many minds will fade.
While it is my ideal that people’s personal religious beliefs be kept out of politics (at least in the most overt way), I also accept that the practical and actual experiences of real people and real countries are not always conducive to this. I also accept that my views will not necessarily be correct. And that there are different paths to the greatest democracy for different countries and different people.
Labels:
democracy,
Egypt,
Islamism,
Middle East,
Tunisia
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)